Personal Injury Attorney in Edisto, SC

COLLETON COUNTY, S.C. (WCSC) - Newly released 911 calls from a massive October fire on Edisto Island reveal four people were trapped inside the home, desperately trying to find a way to escape.

Located on a remote part of the island in the Jeremy Cay Community, the home belonged to State Circuit Judge Diane Goodstein. The Oct. 7 fire sent three people to the hospital, Colleton County Fire Rescue said. One of those patients was airlifted to MUSC, officials said.

Initially, there was speculation the fire was intentionally set, but the South Carolina Law Enforcement Division said of arson.

Colleton County received a total of 16,911 calls from those inside the home and neighbors who described seeing the property up in flames.

The first caller, presumed to be Diane Goodstein’s husband, Arnold Goodstein, is heard yelling fire with alarms in the home sounding.

“We are on Edisto Island. We gotta get out of there,” he said.

A dispatcher asked him if there were people inside the house and Arnold Goodstein said four people were trapped.

“No, we’re trapped! We are trapped in the house,” he replied.

He continued to tell a dispatcher that the fire was coming from under the house. What sounded like explosions are heard on the call, with continued confusion and yelling occurring in the background.

The house’s first floor is elevated from the ground and the injured had to jump to the ground, including Arnold Goodstein, whom can be heard physically jumping along with his reaction to hitting the ground.

“Help! I broke my legs. Help,” he said.

His son soon took over the 911 call and said they were not inside the home anymore after jumping off a balcony.

“He’s 81. He jumped. He hurt his leg,” the son said.

Other voices continue in the background of the phone call, with concerns mounting as the emergency unfolded.

“Get to the water, just to be safe,” a voice on the call said. “I am worried about the propane tank. It’s going to blow.”

Video from the fire department showed the home fully engulfed in flames. Drone photos taken over the scene later showed only a few charred wooden supports standing amid the blackened rubble.

Phone calls from neighbors who also called 911 detail how truly large the fire was.

“There is a ton of smoke out here. It just started about five minutes ago,” one caller said. “Holy s***. That’s fully engulfed.”

“The whole house is in flames. Oh my god,” another neighbor said.

SLED’s investigation is still underway.

“At this time, there is no evidence to indicate the fire was intentionally set,” SLED Chief Mark Keel said. “SLED agents have preliminarily found there is no evidence to support a pre-fire explosion.”

Copyright 2025 WCSC. All rights reserved.

The “Music Lovers Music Festival” – better known as the Edisto Blackwater Boogie – is coming back for a sixth year. The annual celebration is Nov. 7-9 at Givhans Ferry State Park, and funds will benefit an Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA)-compliant trail. Organizers described the lineup as “roots music.”

“We like to explore as many genres as possible, so we use the term ‘roots’ to really cover just about any kind of music you can find here in the U.S.,” said Community Music Collective founder Dan Riley, who helped bring the festival together. “You’ll find everything from folk to blues, country, rock, bluegrass, R&B. We’re just trying to keep expanding that to as many genres as possible.”

The three-day festival includes performances, food vendors and camping. Riley said there will be vegan, vegetarian and gluten-free dining options. For camping, visitors can choose the most suitable pass option from the selection on the event website’s tickets page (zeffy.com/ticketing/ebb--2025). Well-behaved pets are allowed if collared and leashed.

“One of my favorite things about the entire festival is that when the actual stage is shut down at the end of the night, we have a bonfire, and a lot of the artists and our campers will come out around the bonfire and gather to play music around the fire until the wee hours of the morning,” Riley said. “Often, that’s one of my favorite parts. It’s kind of where I think some of the best music of the entire festival happens.”

The Edisto Blackwater Boogie began in 2019 but did not return during the COVID-19 pandemic; it returned the following year and, over time, has raised more than $20,000 for the ADA-compliant trail, Riley said.

“It’s all about celebrating the outdoors and local music,” Riley said. “Just creating a community of people that are accepting and loving each other.”

South Carolina court officials confirm an ongoing investigation into a shocking house fire reportedly tied to Circuit Court Judge Diane Goodstein, sparking statewide concern and speculation.

A quiet weekend on South Carolina’s scenic Edisto Beach turned into a scene of chaos and concern as a powerful house fire tore through a beachfront property early Saturday morning. Within minutes, thick black smoke and flames engulfed the luxury home — and by the time emergency crews arrived, three people were injured, one of them critically.

The South Carolina Law Enforcement Division (SLED) has now taken over the investigation amid growing public curiosity — because this was not just any home. According to multiple sources, the house is reportedly associated with Circuit Court Judge Diane Goodstein, a well-known figure in South Carolina’s judiciary.

The Fire That Shook Edisto Beach

The blaze broke out in the Jeremy Cay community, a private gated area on Edisto Beach known for its high-value beachfront properties. Colleton County Fire-Rescue teams rushed to the scene after receiving emergency calls shortly before 10 a.m. Witnesses described an explosion-like sound moments before the fire erupted, leading to widespread speculation that the incident may have been more than an accident.

Three individuals were rescued from the burning home. According to local reports, one victim was airlifted to the Medical University of South Carolina (MUSC), while two others were transported by ground ambulance to nearby hospitals. Their conditions remain undisclosed, but officials have confirmed that all three are receiving medical care.

SLED officials have remained tight-lipped but confirmed in a brief statement:

> “SLED is investigating a house fire in Colleton County. The investigation remains active and ongoing.”

Within hours of the fire, South Carolina Supreme Court Chief Justice John W. Kittredge released an official statement on behalf of the state judiciary, confirming that the property involved in the fire “appears to be associated with Circuit Court Judge Diane Goodstein.”

Chief Justice Kittredge further added:

> “SLED and local authorities are fully engaged in determining the cause of the fire. The judiciary stands in full support of our law enforcement partners and the affected family.”

While court officials have not suggested foul play, the use of words like “appears to be associated” has fueled public speculation about the true nature of the incident.

Who Is Judge Diane Goodstein?

Judge Diane Goodstein is one of South Carolina’s most respected Circuit Court judges, known for her long career on the bench and high-profile rulings. She recently gained national attention after a controversial judicial decision involving state election data, a case that sparked heated political debate.

Her home’s connection to this sudden blaze has therefore attracted immense attention from both media outlets and the public. While there is no confirmed link between her judicial work and the fire, some observers have raised concerns that the incident could be an act of intimidation or retaliation.

Speculations and Security Concerns

Though authorities have not confirmed the cause, early eyewitness accounts described a loud “boom” before flames erupted, leading some to suspect an explosion or possible arson. The investigation is expected to include forensic analysis of debris, fire patterns, and potential accelerants at the site.

Given the judge’s public role, security experts have urged authorities to consider all possibilities, including targeted violence. In recent years, several high-profile judges across the United States have faced threats related to politically sensitive rulings, prompting nationwide discussions about judicial safety.

A Community in Shock

Residents of Edisto Beach are stunned by the event. “You never expect something like this to happen here,” said one local homeowner. “This is a quiet, peaceful community — everyone knows everyone.”

Local officials have increased patrols in the area, and nearby residents are cooperating with investigators as they piece together the timeline leading up to the explosion.

What Happens Next

SLED’s fire investigation unit will now conduct a detailed examination of the scene to determine whether this was an accident, electrical failure, or intentional act. Investigators are also reviewing security footage from nearby homes and businesses.

Meanwhile, Judge Goodstein and her family have not made a public statement. The judiciary has confirmed that she is safe but deeply shaken by the event.

As the investigation continues, South Carolinians are left waiting for answers — and wondering whether this fire was a tragic accident or something more sinister.

Conclusion

The Edisto Beach fire has become one of South Carolina’s most closely watched investigations. With a respected judge’s name linked to the property, the implications reach far beyond a simple house fire. The outcome of SLED’s probe will determine whether this was merely an unfortunate tragedy or a targeted act against a member of the state’s judicial system.

Until then, the community remains on edge — united by concern, speculation, and a shared hope that justice, in every sense, will prevail.

EDISTO ISLAND — No human factors contributed to the blaze that burned a South Carolina judge’s home to the ground sparking a stream of speculation about what — or who — was responsible for the inferno, according to new details from the local fire department.

The Edisto Beach Fire Department received the first reports of a house fire at 10:38 a.m. on Oct. 4, according to an incident report provided to The Post and Courier on Oct. 16. The newspaper submitted a public records request for the document on Oct. 6.

What triggered the fire has not been determined, with the newly released report only stating no human act was a contributor.

SLED Chief Mark Keel previously stated the cause is not believed to be arson.

The three-story, 4,200-square-foot home belonged to Circuit Judge Diane Goodstein and her husband, former state senator Arnold Goodstein. Edisto Island residents and faraway social media users alike began wondering if the cause was related to Goodstein’s recent ruling that temporarily blocked a demand from President Donald Trump’s administration for voter data. The speculation began while video footage of crackling orange flames and a thick plume of black smoke spread online.

Within 13 minutes of the first call, units had arrived at the home after navigating the thin dirt road and green metal gates that block the private Jeremy Cay Community off from the public.

The home sits off Planters Retreat Drive and atop a peninsula, according to the report. The position of the flames that engulfed the home and three vehicles blocked first responders from reaching four people who were stranded in the marshy backyard.

As firefighters began drafting water out of a nearby pond, EMS and good Samaritans devised a plan to rescue the former legislator and three family members. The judge was not home when the fire began.

A neighbor’s canoe floated the family from the peninsula to an adjacent bank, where they were transported to hospitals.

At one point during the three hours and 35 minutes that firefighters remained on the scene, one unit had to “reposition their apparatus due to explosions at the front of the house,” according to the incident report, which does not further elaborate about the explosions.

The report, which was printed at 5:12 p.m. on Oct. 7, said it was “undetermined” what first ignited the blaze, where it originated or what was the heat source.

It was not confirmed whether a detector was present in the home, though the report did clarify that no auto-extinguishing system was found.

Property damage was estimated at $2 million and $150,000 in content losses resulted from the blaze.

The report clarified that no human factors contributed to the incident. The cause of ignition was listed as “under investigation,” which is being led by the State Law Enforcement Division.

Keel issued a statement on Oct. 6 that confirmed SLED had not found any evidence that indicated the fire was deliberately set or caused by a detonation.

The agency has not made another public statement. Its investigation remains ongoing.

Three people were hospitalized with injuries as a result of the fire.

There’s no sign of arson in the weekend fire that destroyed the beachfront home owned by South Carolina Circuit Court Judge Diane Goodstein, the state’s top law enforcement official said Monday.

“At this time, there is no evidence to indicate the fire was intentionally set,” State Law Enforcement Division (SLED) Chief Mark Keel said in a statement. “SLED agents have preliminarily found there is no evidence to support a pre-fire explosion.”

Keel said his agents would publish a report once they completed their investigation and determined a cause, and did not elaborate.

The blaze broke out during the day Saturday, quickly enveloping the entire house in flames. While there were some reports of an explosion beforehand, that had not been corroborated. Three people were hospitalized, one of them airlifted, after jumping out a back window to escape. They included Goodstein’s husband, former Democratic state lawmaker Arnold Goodstein, who reportedly broke several bones.

Responders needed kayaks to reach the home’s occupants, including the injured, given the house’s location among trees and abutting a marsh.

Arson accusations started flying even as the rubble that had once been the $1.1 million house still smoldered. The arson assumption flared against the backdrop of threats against judges who have been challenging Trump administration policies as well as against those upholding conservative interpretations of the law.

The fire came about a month after Goodstein temporarily blocked the U.S. Department of Justice’s request for sensitive information on the state’s registered voters, a ruling soon reversed by the state Supreme Court.

It is rare for SLED to make statements about investigations that are in progress, but Keel took the opportunity to quell all the speculation and quash misinformation.

“I urge our citizens, elected officials, and members of the press to exercise good judgement and not share information that has not been verified,” wrote Keel. He was backed by Gov. Henry McMaster.

“SLED Chief Mark Keel has announced that at this point in the investigation there is no evidence the horrific fire at Judge Goodstein’s Edisto home was intentionally set,” McMaster wrote on X. “I echo Chief Keel’s call for everyone to exercise good judgment and avoid sharing unverified information while the investigation continues.”

With News Wire Services